Cigna vs. UnitedHealthcare Medigap Plans in Texas
When Texans compare Medicare Supplement plans, two names usually rise to the top: Cigna Healthcare and UnitedHealthcare.
Both are nationally trusted, both offer the major Medigap options (Plan G, Plan N, and High-Deductible G), and both follow the same standardized Medicare rules.
So what’s the difference?
Cigna often wins on affordability, delivering some of the lowest Plan G and Plan N premiums across Texas.
UnitedHealthcare wins on brand trust and perks, large-scale support, and popular wellness benefits.
This guide walks you through the real distinctions - plan offerings, pricing, discounts, and overall experience - so you can decide which carrier aligns better with your budget and the way you prefer to use your Medicare coverage.
Cigna Medicare Supplement Overview
Cigna Healthcare has become one of the go-to Medigap carriers for people who want strong coverage without paying more than they need to.
It’s a nationally recognized brand with a growing Texas footprint - and it consistently shows up as one of the most affordable options for new Medicare enrollees.
Plans Offered in Texas:
Cigna provides all the major Medigap choices most retirees look for: Plan G, Plan N, and High-Deductible Plan G (HDG). These plans are accepted by any doctor or hospital that takes Medicare, giving you complete freedom of choice statewide and nationwide.
Where Cigna Stands Out:
- Lower premiums: Cigna is routinely among the lowest-priced Plan G and Plan N carriers in many Texas ZIP codes.
- Generous household discounts: Many idividuals qualify for meaningful savings just by living with another Medicare-eligible adult.
- Easy digital experience: Their online portal, billing tools, and claims system are all built for convenience - ideal if you prefer managing your coverage online.
- Quick, reliable claims service: Cigna has a strong track record of fast approvals and straightforward customer support.
Summary:
Cigna is an excellent fit for budget-focused people who want dependable Medigap coverage at a fair price. If your priority is keeping premiums low while still getting strong nationwide access, Cigna is a great place to start your comparison.
UnitedHealthcare Medicare Supplement Overview
UnitedHealthcare is one of the largest and most established Medicare Supplement carriers in the country, and it has a strong presence throughout Texas.
With broad provider familiarity and a long track record of steady performance, UHC is a go-to choice for retirees who want dependable coverage backed by a major national brand.
Plans Offered in Texas:
UnitedHealthcare offers the two most popular Medigap options - Plan G and Plan N - both widely available across Texas ZIP codes. Benefits are standardized, but UHC differentiates itself through its member perks and longevity in the market.
Where UHC Stands Out:
- National brand strength: Providers across Texas recognize and work with UnitedHealthcare every day, making claims and coordination smoother.
- Renew Active fitness program: A standout wellness perk with gym access, brain-health tools, and activity tracking at no extra cost.
- Strong digital tools: Easy online account access and reliable customer support make managing your plan simple.
Summary:
UnitedHealthcare is an excellent fit for those that who want dependable Medigap coverage, valuable fitness perks, and the peace of mind that comes with a major national insurer.
What Medigap Plans Do They Offer?
When you line up Cigna and UnitedHealthcare side by side, you’ll notice something important right away: both companies offer the same core Medigap plans beneficiieies rely on most.
The benefits for each plan letter are standardized by Medicare, so what you’re really choosing between is the company, the premium, and the experience you prefer.
These three plans below make up the vast majority of Medigap enrollments in Texas.
#1. Plan G
This is the “set-it-and-forget-it” option.
Plan G covers almost every out-of-pocket cost that Original Medicare leaves behind, except the small Part B deductible.
It’s the most comprehensive plan new enrollees can buy today and the one we see most people gravitate toward for its simplicity and predictability.
#2. Plan N
Plan N is great if you want to save on your monthly premium and don’t mind a couple of small copays along the way.
You’ll see things like a modest office-visit copay or an ER copay if you aren’t admitted - still very manageable, especially if you don’t visit the doctor often.
#3. High-Deductible Plan G (HDG)
HDG takes the same benefits as Plan G and gives them a much lower monthly premium by attaching a higher annual deductible.
It’s a smart fit if you’re healthy, want strong protection for major events, and prefer to keep your monthly costs as low as possible.
Note: Both carriers may offer other letters - like Plan A or Plan F for those who qualified before 2020 - but for most people, Plan G, Plan N, and HDG are the plans worth focusing on.
Important Reminder: Benefits Are Identical
No matter who you choose - Cigna or UnitedHealthcare - Plan G is Plan G. Plan N is Plan N. HDG is HDG.
The coverage, coinsurance, deductibles, and what Medicare approves are the same across every carrier.
Where the real differences show up are in:
- Monthly premiums
- Discount programs
- Customer experience
- Digital tools and ease of use
How to Decide Which Plan Letter Fits You
Here’s the short version:
- Pick Plan G if you want the most coverage and the fewest surprises.
- Pick Plan N if you’re healthy and want a lower monthly premium with a couple small copays.
- Pick HDG if you’re budget-minded and want premium savings while still protecting yourself from major expenses.
Feature Comparison: Plan G vs. Plan N
Before comparing Cigna and UnitedHealthcare, it’s important to understand how the two most popular Medigap plans - Plan G and Plan N - actually work.
Both fill the major gaps left by Original Medicare, but they do it in slightly different ways.
Plan G: The Full-Coverage Favorite
Plan G is the most comprehensive Medigap plan available to new Medicare enrollees.
After you meet the small Part B deductible, Plan G steps in and covers:
- All Part A hospital coinsurance
- All Part B coinsurance
- Skilled nursing facility coinsurance
- Hospice care coinsurance
- Blood (first 3 pints)
- Part B excess charges
- Foreign travel emergency coverage (up to plan limits)
What it feels like: You pay your Part B deductible once per year, and then nearly everything else Medicare approves is covered at 100%. It’s simple, predictable, and great for anyone who wants zero surprises.
Plan N: Same Solid Coverage, With a Lower Premium
Plan N offers almost the same protection as Plan G, but trades a little convenience for a lower monthly premium.
Under Plan N, you get:
- Full Part A coinsurance
- Full Part B coinsurance
- Foreign travel emergency coverage
- Skilled nursing facility coverage
- Hospice coverage
- Blood (first 3 pints)
The key differences:
- Office visit copay: Up to $20
- ER copay: Up to $50 (waived if admitted)
- No coverage for Part B excess charges
- Part B deductible not covered (same as Plan G)
What it feels like: You save money each month, and in exchange, you may pay a few small copays here and there. For many healthy individulas, those savings easily outweigh the occasional copay.
Quick Summary
Plan G = full coverage and simplicity. Once your deductible is paid, your costs are nearly zero for Medicare-approved services.
Plan N = strong value with a lower monthly premium. A good fit if you want solid protection and don’t mind a small copay now and then.
Plan G Premium Comparison in Texas
When you compare Cigna and UnitedHealthcare for Medicare Supplement Plan G in Texas, the biggest difference shows up in the monthly premium - and your ZIP code plays a major role.
Why the Difference?
Premium differences come down to:
- Pricing method (Cigna uses attained-age pricing; UHC uses community pricing on some versions)
- Built-in perks (UHC often bundles wellness benefits, which can raise premiums)
- Discount structures (Cigna’s household discounts can lower rates substantially)
- ZIP code factors (Texas varies widely between metro and rural pricing)
Who usually wins on price? For most ZIP codes, Cigna tends to come in lower on initial premiums, especially when the household discount is applied.
UnitedHealthcare may cost a bit more upfront but offers fairly predictable renewals thanks to its large member pool and community-rated structure.
Quick Summary
Cigna = Lower starting premiums + strong discounts
UHC = Higher base price but strong stability + broader brand familiarity
Both companies offer excellent Plan G coverage - the right fit will depend on what you value most in a provider.
Plan N Premium Comparison in Texas
Plan N is one of the most popular alternatives to Plan G because it trims the monthly premium while still covering the major Medicare gaps.
You’ll see small copays for doctor and ER visits, and excess charges aren’t covered - but many Texans find the savings well worth it.
When we pull the lowest available Texas Plan N premiums, the difference between Cigna and UnitedHealthcare becomes pretty clear: Cigna usually enters the market with the lower starting premium.
Here’s a simplified side-by-side look at their lowest entry premiums for a 65-year-old non-smoker in Texas:
High-Deductible Plan G Premium Comparison (Texas)
When it comes to High-Deductible Plan G (HDG), the difference between Cigna and UnitedHealthcare is simple: only one of them offers it in Texas.
Cigna comes in with one of the most competitive HDG options in the state, starting around $69 per month for many Texas ZIP codes.
It’s a strong fit for retirees who want the lowest possible premium while still keeping full Plan G coverage after meeting the annual deductible.
UnitedHealthcare does not offer a High-Deductible Plan G in Texas based on the most recent Medicare.gov rate filings.
If HDG is the plan you want, UHC isn’t an option - you’ll need to choose another carrier.
Discounts, Perks and Member Experience
When you’re comparing Cigna and UnitedHealthcare (UHC), the premiums are just one part of the story.
The real value shows up in the discounts, extras, and day-to-day experience each carrier offers.
Here’s how they differ in ways that actually matter.
Cigna
Household Discounts
Cigna is known for offering solid household savings when two Medicare-eligible adults live together and enroll in a Cigna Medigap plan.
In many Texas ZIP codes, this discount can land around 7% or more - a meaningful reduction when you’re watching monthly expenses.
Digital Tools and Service
Cigna keeps things simple. Their online enrollment, bill-pay, and claims tools are straightforward and easy to use.
If you prefer managing your coverage online without needing to call customer service every time, Cigna makes that experience smooth.
Budget-Friendly Approach
Cigna is one of the most consistently affordable Medigap carriers in Texas.
If your goal is strong coverage at a lighter monthly premium, Cigna delivers - without sacrificing the essentials.
Takeaway: Cigna saves you money. It’s a great fit for cost-conscious policy holders who want dependable Medigap coverage at a lower price point.
UnitedHealthcare (UHC)
Wellness and Fitness Perks
UHC stands out with Renew Active, one of the most robust fitness and brain-health programs in the Medigap space.
Members get access to gyms, workout classes, and online wellness tools at no extra cost - a big perk if you’re active or want to stay that way.
Additional Discounts and Extras
UHC often includes extra savings on vision, hearing, and even dental services.
These aren’t full insurance plans, but they can cut down costs on everyday healthcare needs, which many retirees appreciate.
Brand Strength and Provider Recognition
UnitedHealthcare is one of the biggest names in Medicare. Texas doctors and hospitals know them, which can make everything feel a little smoother.
Familiarity goes a long way when you’re dealing with healthcare.
Takeaway: UHC gives you perks and familiarity. It’s the right choice if you value a big national brand, wellness extras, and an experience that feels polished and well-supported.
Final Takeaway
If your top priority is saving money every month, Cigna is usually the better fit - especially if you qualify for their household discount.
If you’d rather choose a carrier with bigger perks, strong name recognition, and nationwide familiarity, UHC may be worth the slightly higher premium.
Just remember: Prices and discounts can vary by ZIP code. The best way to know which one truly comes out cheapest for you is to compare them side by side based on your age, county, and eligibility for discounts.
Which Company Is Right for You?
When you’re choosing between Cigna and UnitedHealthcare, it really comes down to what you value most - savings, perks, or overall feel.
Both carriers offer solid Medicare Supplement coverage, but they shine in different ways.
Choose Cigna if you want:
- Lower monthly premiums in most Texas ZIP codes
- Generous household discounts that can drive costs down even further
- A clean, digital-friendly experience for managing claims and billing
Cigna tends to be the budget winner, and when the benefits are identical across carriers, saving money without sacrificing coverage is a smart move.
Choose UnitedHealthcare if you want:
- Strong brand recognition and provider familiarity
- Renew Active included - one of the best fitness programs in Medigap
UHC often costs a bit more, but some people feel the added wellness perks and national footprint are worth it.
How to Compare Cigna and UHC Rates in Texas
Comparing Medicare Supplement plans doesn’t have to turn into a research project. With a few quick steps - and a little help from Policy Guide - you can find the right fit without the stress.
#1. Start with your ZIP code. Texas premiums vary a lot from one county to the next. Before you look at anything else, check the rates in your exact ZIP code. That alone can change which company comes out on top.
#2. Compare Plan G, Plan N, and High-Deductible G side by side. Make sure you're comparing the same plan letter across both companies.
Plan G vs. Plan G, Plan N vs. Plan N - that’s the only way to get a true apples-to-apples comparison since the benefits are identical.
#3. Factor in discounts vs. perks. Cigna’s household discount can drop your premium noticeably if two people in the same home enroll.
UHC, on the other hand, shines with wellness perks like Renew Active.
Think about whether monthly savings or added benefits matter more to you.
#4. Choose the carrier that fits your lifestyle. If your top priority is affordability, Cigna usually wins.
If you prefer brand familiarity and wellness benefits, UHC is likely a better match.
Policy Guide Makes It Easy
Instead of calling carriers one by one or sifting through confusing brochures, our licensed agents compare your actual rates from both companies in real time.
We show you which option is cheaper in your ZIP code, where you qualify for discounts, and how each carrier’s rates have been trending.
No pressure, no sales pitch - just clear, honest guidance from people who do this every day.
Final Thoughts
When you stack Cigna and UnitedHealthcare side by side, you’re really choosing between two quality Medicare Supplement carriers - but each one appeals to a different type of Texan.
Cigna is the go-to pick for affordability and value. Their lower premiums and generous household discounts make them hard to beat, especially if your goal is to get solid Medigap protection without paying more than you need to.
For many, Cigna delivers the best balance of price and dependability.
UnitedHealthcare, on the other hand, shines for those who want brand recognition, built-in perks like Renew Active, and a carrier that nearly every provider in Texas already knows well.
Both companies offer identical Medigap benefits for the same plan letter - but what you actually pay each month can look very different. That’s why comparing your rates is the single biggest step you can take to avoid overpaying.
Our take? If we’re looking strictly at overall value, Cigna typically comes out ahead - especially for Plan G and Plan N.
But your ZIP code, age, and discount eligibility ultimately decide who’s cheapest for you.
FAQs
Yes. While both companies follow Medicare’s standard guidelines, their underwriting flexibility can differ. If you are switching from another Medigap plan, these differences can impact how easily you qualify.
Coverage is the same. Any doctor or hospital that accepts Medicare will accept either Medigap plan. The only difference you may notice is administrative familiarity. UnitedHealthcare is a very recognizable national brand, so many provider offices are accustomed to their billing processes. Cigna is also widely accepted, but smaller practices may be slightly less familiar with their Medigap workflow. This does not affect your benefits, only the behind-the-scenes process.
Yes, each company structures it in its own way. Cigna typically offers a household discount of around 7 percent and, in many Texas ZIP codes, allows the discount even if another Medicare-eligible adult lives in the home, provided that person is not enrolled with Cigna. UnitedHealthcare’s discount rules vary by county and often require both household members to enroll with UHC to qualify. For couples or roommates, these differences can lead to significant savings.
Both companies offer digital tools, but they appeal to different preferences. Cigna’s online platform tends to feel very streamlined and simple, making tasks like bill payment, ID retrieval, and claims lookup easy for those who want a straightforward digital experience without unnecessary extras. UnitedHealthcare’s online system includes more tools, including wellness integrations through Renew Active and enhanced support features. It is more robust, though sometimes more complex for users who prefer simplicity.
Both Cigna and UnitedHealthcare offer identical foreign travel emergency benefits under Plan G, Plan N, and High-Deductible G because these benefits are standardized by Medicare. The difference lies in the support experience. Cigna provides a straightforward claims process that many frequent travelers appreciate, while UnitedHealthcare’s larger national infrastructure may feel more reassuring for those who prefer broad, well-known support channels when dealing with overseas claims. The coverage itself is the same, but the service experience can feel slightly different depending on your personal comfort level.
With nearly 15 years of experience in the insurance industry, Matt Kiggins is the Senior Editor at Texas Insurance Guide and a seasoned Health & Life Agent licensed in multiple states, including Texas (#1585860). He is also the co-founder of Policy Guide, a respected insurance agency based in Pensacola, FL. Matt has built his career on one simple principle: people deserve clear, honest guidance when making some of life’s most important healthcare decisions.
Or enter your zip code to shop online